Current:Home > InvestSupreme Court sides with Christian postal worker who declined to work on Sundays -ValueCore
Supreme Court sides with Christian postal worker who declined to work on Sundays
View
Date:2025-04-18 00:51:47
Washington — The Supreme Court on Thursday sided with a Christian mail carrier who declined to work on Sundays, bolstering protections for workers seeking religious accommodations from their employers.
In a unanimous decision in the case known as Groff v. DeJoy, the court declined to overturn a key 1977 precedent that said employers can deny accommodations for an employee's religious practices if the request imposes more than a "de minimis," or minimal, cost on the business.
But it set aside the "de minimis" standard set more than 45 years ago and laid out a "clarified standard" for lower courts to apply to determine when, under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, an employee's proposed religious accommodation imposes an undue hardship on the employer's business.
As Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the majority, courts "should resolve whether a hardship would be substantial in the context of an employer's business in the commonsense manner that it would use in applying any such test."
"We think it is enough to say that an employer must show that the burden of granting an accommodation would result in substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business," he wrote.
The Supreme Court tossed out the lower court's decision against the U.S. Postal Service worker, Gerald Groff, and sent the case back for further legal proceedings.
Title VII prohibits an employer from discriminating against a worker because of their religion. Under the law, an employer must reasonably accommodate an employee's religious observance or practice unless it would result in "undue hardship" on the business.
In its 1977 decision in Trans World Airlines v. Hardison, the Supreme Court said an "undue hardship" is an accommodation that would cause an employer to bear more than a "de minimis" cost.
Thursday's ruling is the latest in a string of decisions from the conservative Supreme Court in favor of religious parties. In its last term, the high court sided with a former high school football coach who was punished for praying on the field after games, and found that schools that provide religious instruction could not be excluded from a tuition assistance program offered by the state of Maine.
This latest dispute arose from Groff's objections to working on Sundays after the Postal Service entered into an agreement with Amazon for Sunday package deliveries. Groff, an Evangelical Christian, said his religious beliefs prevented him from working those days because he observes the Sabbath on Sunday.
Groff was exempted from Sunday work while he was employed as a Rural Carrier Associate, or part-time mail carrier, at the post office in Quarryville, Pennsylvania. That changed when he transferred to a smaller station in Holtwood, Pennsylvania, that began Sunday deliveries in 2017.
The postmaster of the Holtwood Post Office refused to exempt Groff from Sunday delivery, but offered to seek volunteers to cover his shifts. Still, he ultimately missed 24 shifts when a replacement carrier couldn't be secured to accommodate his absence.
After the Postal Service took disciplinary action against Groff due to his missed shifts, he resigned in 2019. Groff then sued the Postal Service in federal court, alleging it violated Title VII. A federal district court ruled in favor of the Postal Service, and a divided panel of judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit affirmed the ruling.
The appeals court found that exempting Groff from working on Sundays "caused more than a de minimis cost on USPS because it actually imposed on his coworkers, disrupted the workplace and workflow, and diminished employee morale."
But the Supreme Court said that when faced with a request for an accommodation like Groff's, "it would not be enough for an employer to conclude that forcing other employees to work overtime would constitute an undue hardship. Consideration of other options, such as voluntary shift swapping, would also be necessary."
The court said the Postal Service could still prevail in its dispute with Groff, leaving the question to the lower courts to decide under the "clarified standard."
- In:
- Supreme Court of the United States
veryGood! (7424)
Related
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Survivors say opportunities were missed that could have prevented Maine’s worst-ever mass shooting
- Judge upholds Tennessee law to stop crossover voting in primaries. Critics say the law is too vague.
- Noah Cyrus Frees the Nipple During Paris Fashion Week Outing With Fiancé Pinkus
- Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie return for an 'Encore,' reminisce about 'The Simple Life'
- France becomes the only country in the world to guarantee abortion as a constitutional right
- Travis Kelce Breaks Down in Tears Watching Brother Jason Kelce's Retirement Announcement
- Alabama Supreme Court IVF Ruling Renews Focus on Plastics, Chemical Exposure and Infertility
- EU countries double down on a halt to Syrian asylum claims but will not yet send people back
- 4 astronauts launch to space, heading to International Space Station: Meet the crew
Ranking
- Megan Fox's ex Brian Austin Green tells Machine Gun Kelly to 'grow up'
- Three-man, one-woman crew ready for weather-delayed launch to space station
- Survivors say opportunities were missed that could have prevented Maine’s worst-ever mass shooting
- New Massachusetts license plate featuring 'Cat in the Hat' honors Springfield native Dr. Seuss
- The Best Stocking Stuffers Under $25
- 4 astronauts launch to space, heading to International Space Station: Meet the crew
- Here's how to negotiate a lower commission fee from your real estate agent
- 4 astronauts launch to space, heading to International Space Station: Meet the crew
Recommendation
North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
Tennessee, Houston headline winners and losers from men's basketball weekend
Joshua Jackson and Lupita Nyong'o Confirm Romance With PDA-Filled Tropical Getaway
One Tech Tip: Change these settings on X to limit calls and hide your IP address
Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
NFL world honors 'a wonderful soul' after Chris Mortensen's death at 72
Supreme Court temporarily blocks Texas law that allows police to arrest migrants
Eagles center Jason Kelce retires after 13 NFL seasons and 1 Super Bowl ring